- What Is
- Dissection vs. Resection
- EMR vs. ESD
Which endoscopic techniques are done for treating colon cancer or polyps?
- Endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR): This procedure removes early-stage cancer and precancerous growths from the lining of the digestive tract. It works better with superficial masses.
- Endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD): This procedure removes large tumors from the gastrointestinal tract.
- Polypectomy: This procedure is used to remove polyps (an abnormal collection of tissue) from the inside of the colon.
What is the difference between dissection and resection?
- Resection: This is a surgical procedure used to remove a part of an organ or a structure, possibly because of disease or cancer (e.g., the tumor resected after chemotherapy).
- Dissection: This is a procedure of cuts apart or separates tissue for further study or diagnosis. It helps in removing a complete part that is affected by the disease (e.g., autopsy).
How is an endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR) performed?
Endoscopic mucosal resection is performed with a target to capture the diseased tissue. An electrosurgical current is used to cut the tissue that has been grasped.
An injection is usually administered in the submucosal space (a lining in the colon) to elevate the lesion but is not always necessary; some techniques, such as underwater endoscopic mucosal resection, do not require an injection into the submucosa.
If the lesion is larger than 15 to 20 mm, it typically must be removed in a nonsystematic fashion. The main use of an endoscopic mucosal resection is to remove polyps that are larger than 10 mm.
How is an endoscopic submucosal dissection performed?
An endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) is performed by injecting fluid into the submucosa (a lining on the colon) and creating an incision around the perimeter of the diseased part or lesion and then carefully dissecting the lesion from the deeper layers. Various specialized instruments (ESD knives) are utilized to perform the procedure.
An ESD is endorsed for lesions that have a high likelihood of aggressive cancer that have high chances to invade other parts. It is used when lesions cannot be removed by an endoscopic mucosal resection or when lesions reoccur after the endoscopic mucosal resection procedure.
What is the difference between an endoscopic mucosal resection (EMR) and endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD)?
- EMR is easier to learn and perform, has a lower risk of adverse events, and carries a low-cost burden. It continues to be the more commonly performed endoscopic resection procedure.
- Endoscopists have limited experience with an ESD, and there is no reimbursement for this procedure in few parts of the world. There is limited incentive to learn and perform this more complex and high-risk procedure by endoscopists.
- Each technique has its own advantages and disadvantages. EMR is relatively simple to perform, uses a limited number of devices and has a long track record of being successful for most precancerous lesions. Its main disadvantage is that some patients who are treated with this procedure may require additional surgery. However, if they had been treated with ESD, they may have been cured. The other major disadvantage of EMR is that it has a high lesion recurrence rate in the range of 15% to 20%, which necessitates further therapy.
- The main advantage of ESD is that it allows complete dissection of any type of lesion regardless of size. Removing the entire lesion in a single piece is a basic oncologic principle and carries the benefits of accurate histological assessment and staging, determination of curative resection and a very low recurrence rate of less than 1%. However, it is technically more demanding than EMR and requires advanced endoscopy skills. Furthermore, ESD is a relatively complex procedure associated with a higher perforation rate compared with EMR. Fortunately, most perforations caused by an ESD can be successfully treated by endoscopy without the need for surgery.
Health Solutions From Our Sponsors
Top What Is the Difference Between EMR and ESD Related Articles
Colon CancerColon cancer (bowel cancer) is a malignancy that arises from the inner lining of the colon. Most, if not all, of these cancers develop from colonic polyps. Removal of these precancerous polyps can prevent colon cancer.
Colon Cancer DietDiet, including nutrient, antioxidant, and vitamin intake, affects colon cancer risk. Certain dietary factors either decrease or increase the risk of colorectal cancer, breast cancer, and other diseases. Dietary factors may either inhibit or stimulate the development of cancer cells. Have a nutrition plan that decreases the risk.
Colon Cancer IllustrationsMost, if not all, of these cancers develop from colonic polyps. Removal of these precancerous polyps can prevent colon cancer. See a picture of Colon Cancer and learn more about the health topic.
Colon Cancer Prevention
Colorectal cancer is both curable and preventable if it is detected early and completely removed before the cancerous cells metastasize to other parts of the body. Colonoscopy and flexible sigmoidoscopy (along with digital rectal examination and stool occult blood testing) are both effective at preventing colo-rectal cancers and detecting early colo-rectal cancers.
Colon and Colorectal Cancer ScreeningColon cancer is preventable by removing precancerous colon polyps, and it is curable if early cancer is surgically removed before cancer spreads to other parts of the body. Therefore, if screening and surveillance programs were practiced universally, there would be a major reduction in the incidence and mortality of colorectal cancer.
Colon Polyps: Symptoms, Causes, Cancer Risk, Treatment, and PreventionColon polyps are common growths on the inner lining of the colon. Colon polyps may become cancerous. There are several different types of colon polyps, and the chance of the polyp becoming cancerous depends on the type, size, and histology. Blood in the stool or rectal bleeding are the most common symptoms of colon polyps. Treatment for colon polyps depend on the type, size, and histology.
Colonoscopy Procedure and PreparationA colonoscopy is a procedure whereby a docotor inserts a viewing tube (colonoscope) into the rectum for the purpose of inspecting the colon. Colonoscopy is the best method currently available to diagnose, detect, and treat abnormalities within the colon.
Colorectal (Colon) Cancer QuizWhat is colorectal (colon) cancer and who gets it? Take this quiz to find out how this disease may be prevented.
Colon Cancer SlideshowColorectal cancer (colon cancer) is the cause of many cancer deaths. Learn about the warning signs, symptoms, screening process, stages, and treatment related to colorectal cancer.
Early Warning Signs and Stages of Colon CancerColon cancer or colorectal cancer, is a type of cancer that begins in the cells lining the large intestine (colon). In the early stages of colon cancer, warning signs and symptoms usually don’t occur. Colon cancer usually does not have any signs or symptoms. As the cancer grows and expands it may begin to produce signs and symptoms, for example, diarrhea, constipation, blood in the stool, and narrow or pencil-thin stools.
There are four stages of colon cancer; however, The term Stage 0 is sometimes used for a very early cancer that only affects the lining of the intestine. The other stages of colon cancer are stage 1, 2, 3, and 4.
Endoscopy vs. ColonoscopyBoth endoscopy and colonoscopy are nonsurgical procedures that involve use of a flexible tube with a light and camera to examine parts of the digestive tract. A colonoscopy is a type of endoscopy.
How Painful Is a Colonoscopy?A colonoscopy is a diagnostic procedure to evaluate the health of the colon and rectum. A colonoscopy is done with a colonoscope, a tube with a camera and surgical tools. The doctor can view the the colon, sample tissue for biopsy, or remove polyps. Most people feel nothing more than slight discomfort during the procedure because of mild sedation and pain medication. Some people do not feel much pain even without sedation, but some may experience cramps and pain.
All About PolypsDo you know what a polyp is? Learn the definition of a polyp, which can be found in the sinuses, stomach, colon, gallbladder, and elsewhere. Learn about endometrial polyps, adenomatous polyps, sessile polyps, pedunculated polyps, uterine polyps, and cervical polyps. Some are more likely to cause cancer.
Sigmoidoscopy vs. ColonoscopyBoth sigmoidoscopy and colonoscopy are nonsurgical procedures that involve use of a tube (endoscope) with a light and camera to examine parts of the large intestine (colon). A sigmoidoscopy is a procedure in which a fiberoptic camera is used to examine the rectum and lower part of the colon. The difference between a sigmoidoscopy and colonoscopy is that a colonoscopy examines the upper part of the colon as well.
Virtual ColonoscopyVirtual colonoscopy is a procedure that uses a CT scan to construct virtual images of the colon. Virtual colonoscopy takes approximately 10 minutes, and in comparison to traditional colonoscopy is less invasive and requires no conscious sedation. Virtual colonoscopy may not be recommended for some patients due to their medical history.