What Happens in a Forensic Psychiatric Evaluation?

Medically Reviewed on 5/9/2022
What happens in a forensic psychiatric evaluation?
A forensic psychiatrist testifies as an expert in judicial matters concerning mental health.

The forensic psychiatric evaluation addresses issues of imputability (liability or responsibility) and non-imputability.

A forensic psychiatric evaluation employs clinical psychiatric in-depth interview techniques, but it relies on collateral sources of information, addresses the possibility of malingering (feigned) psychiatric illness more prominently, and attempts to answer specific medical-legal (psychiatric) questions.

It might involve an evaluation of the individual's present mental functioning at the time of the interview, such as:

  • Appearance
  • Affect
  • Behavior
  • Cognitive functions

When performing a forensic psychiatric evaluation, current best practices advocate using various sources of information, such as:

  • Full record review
  • Clinical interview
  • Collateral material
  • Objective psychological testing
  • Actuarial tools

The forensic psychiatric evaluation interview elicits information, such as:

  • A person's psychosocial background
  • Present mental condition
  • Whether the person satisfies the criteria for a psychiatric diagnosis
  • The interview includes both behavioral observations and self-reports from the subject

When is a forensic psychiatric evaluation used?

Forensic psychiatric examinations are conducted at the request of investigative organizations or courts.

  • Articles of the criminal and civil laws, as well as the rules of criminal and civil procedure, describe the way to request and perform such an examination and assess the results.
  • Psychiatrists are guided in their examinations by regulations created by public health agencies.
  • Defendants, witnesses, parties in a civil case, injured parties in a criminal proceeding, and convicted individuals could be subjected to forensic mental tests (at the direction of prison authorities).
  • The primary goal of questioning witnesses and injured parties is to ascertain whether they are capable of fully comprehending the facts of the case and providing accurate testimony.
  • The experts' task in a forensic psychiatric examination of a convicted person who becomes ill while serving their sentence is to determine the nature, severity, and curability. If the accused has symptoms of mental illness, the doctor’s testimony is used to determine whether the convicted person can continue to serve their sentence.
  • The findings of a forensic psychiatric evaluation are delivered in the form of a legally binding written conclusion.

According to the law, the conclusion drawn up after a forensic psychiatric examination, like all other kinds of forensic examinations, is used as evidence. It does not, however, have binding force on bodies of investigation and the court. If these bodies disagree with the conclusion, they must justify their opinion.

A court has the right to impose a more restrictive setting on someone who is assessed to be at a high risk of future violence than on someone who is deemed to be at a lower risk of recidivism. When court verdicts are customized based on credible evaluations, the community is safer, and the defendant's rights are protected.

A forensic psychiatric evaluation is not treatment. Rather, the need for objectivity requires that it be performed outside of a therapeutic relationship. The questions are posed to generate some type of legal participation. Though diagnosis and treatment suggestions may (and frequently are) included in the examination, they are not the primary goal of the evaluation.


Laughter feels good because… See Answer

What is forensic psychiatry?

Forensic psychiatry is a subfield of forensic science. This branch of medicine includes the domains of law, criminal justice, toxicology, and psychiatry. Psychiatric tests, consultations, and testimony help resolve court proceedings and other legal concerns.

Forensic psychiatry can be used in a variety of legal issues, including:

  • Civil
    • Can examine emotional and mental distress claims to determine the extent of harm done to the individual in the issue.
    • Can determine the necessity for a caregiver or the existence of undue influence in circumstances involving someone with a mental health problem.
  • Criminal
    • Can assess a defendant's mental health during criminal prosecution to determine their punishment.
    • Determine if a defendant can stand trial or collaborate with their defense team.
    • Can assess a defendant's mental health at the time the offense occurred.
  • Family
    • Can assess a parent's mental health to determine if they are fit to have legal custody or receive child support.

By addressing critical forensic questions, forensic psychiatry evaluation has become a vital resource for the criminal justice system through assessing the danger of violence, making proper choices on matters, such as sentencing, giving privileges, and community reintegration.

Who is a forensic psychiatrist?

A forensic psychiatrist testifies as an expert in judicial matters concerning mental health. They have completed further studies in forensic medicine and toxicology.

A forensic psychiatrist uses science to explain legal matters. While they are not a lawyer, to work more effectively, they could be knowledgeable about many parts of the legal system. They commonly take part in competency hearings to evaluate if a person is mentally capable of standing trial and examine a person's mental state at the time of a crime.

A forensic psychiatrist may offer the following forensic psychiatry services to legal professionals:

  • Consulting
    • Expert psychiatry consultation can help with trial preparation.
    • Assists legal practitioners in their efforts to comprehend a case's medical and mental difficulties.
  • Evaluations
    • They can conduct the tests required to get vital information in instances needing mental health examinations.
    • They conduct examinations on areas, such as competence, undue influence, suitability for duty, and many more.
  • Expert testimony
    • When a legal practitioner needs an expert witness, they can deliver professional testimony.
    • They can disclose their results in a court of law after finishing consultation or evaluation.

Treatment recommendations, such as punishment, parole, or probation, could be suggested by a forensic psychiatrist. Forensic psychiatrists can work for either the defense or the prosecution, and they can suggest anything from institutionalizing a mentally incompetent criminal to treating a victim suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. They can relate medical and psychological concerns with legal situations due to their knowledge of the physical impacts of mental health illnesses.

Medically Reviewed on 5/9/2022
Image Source: iStock Image

Chadda RK. Forensic evaluations in psychiatry. Indian J Psychiatry. 2013;55(4):393-399. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3890920/

UC Davis Health. Forensic Psychiatry Evaluations. https://health.ucdavis.edu/psychiatry/specialties/forensic/evaluations.html

Glancy GD, Ash P, Bath EP, et al. AAPL Practice Guideline for the Forensic Assessment. J Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 2015 Jun;43(2 Suppl):S3-53.. https://www.aapl.org/docs/pdf/Forensic_Assessment.pdf