Is circumcision good or bad?
Circumcision is a surgical procedure where a doctor removes the skin covering the tip of your penis. In many parts of the world, including the United States, it is common for newborn boys to be circumcised. You can undergo circumcision at any time after the infant period, but the procedure becomes more complex as you age.
While some people practice circumcision as a matter of family tradition, others observe it as a religious ritual. At the basic level, some people consider the procedure unnecessary or cosmetic. There are times, however, when your doctor would deem it necessary to undergo circumcision for preventive health care reasons.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), the benefits of circumcision outweigh the risks. However, the data on which this finding was not based in the North American context. There is growing evidence that circumcision lowers the risk of acquiring the following conditions:
It is also possible that some of the bacteria that accumulate under the foreskin could be shared between sexual partners and cause bacterial vaginosis.
The question of whether sex feels better for a woman who has sex with a circumcised penis is subjective. Aspects of penile anatomy, for instance, the absence of foreskin, is among the numerous factors influencing a woman’s choice of a sexual partner.
However, according to independent research, most women prefer the removal of the foreskin, as it improves penile aesthetics, giving it a desirable appearance. Circumcision can add positive sexual benefits to a man and his sexual partner, including:
More pleasure during intercourse. Generally, most couples report that circumcision helps improve a man's penile aesthetics, but not necessarily their sexual performance or pleasure. Still, a considerable percentage of couples report that their sexual lives improved after the man underwent circumcision. Similarly, research shows that most women enjoy better intimacy and oral sex if their partners are circumcised.
Alternative solution for phimosis. Phimosis occurs as the result of a tight foreskin snagged on the tip of the penis. This is a normal condition in newborns and toddlers. As boys grow, the foreskin is supposed to retract so it can be rolled naturally. However, in most cases, this doesn't happen, resulting in a condition known as phimosis. Usually, the only treatment solution to rectify this situation is to have the foreskin removed (i.e., circumcision).
Promotes better genital hygiene. Usually, the foreskin is a breeding ground for bacteria since it's not always easy to clean the penis beneath the foreskin. However, the procedure makes it easier to clean beneath the skin and maintain a higher standard of genital hygiene, which helps prevent itchiness and infections.
Not only is a good genital hygiene regimen beneficial to men, but women also benefit immensely from male circumcision. According to various studies, a circumcised penis highly improves a woman's sexual and reproductive health. A circumcised and well-maintained penis helps reduce the chances of vaginal infections, including bacterial vaginosis and cervical cancer agents, such as human papillomavirus, in women.
Risks of circumcision
On the flip side, male circumcision has been attributed to a number of health risks, the most serious being excess bleeding. Excessive bleeding is a common complication of the male circumcision procedure.
While the condition may be contained by applying pressure and gel form, in other instances, this may not be enough. It can result in damage to the urethra and possible growth of the fistula. This condition is rare but may occur in small boys with underlying blood dyscrasias or similar blood disorders.
Infection. As is the case with all major surgical procedures, infections are inevitable. However, under the best sterile and hygienic conditions, this complication can be infrequent. Infections are more common in newborns since they are naturally immunocompromised. In the worst and rarest cases, infections arising from a circumcised penis may cause other adverse complications, including meningitis, gangrene, necrotizing fasciitis, and sepsis.
Other adverse effects of male circumcision include:
- Insufficient removal of the foreskin
- Excessive removal of the foreskin
- Penile adhesion
- Cyst inclusion
- Abnormal healing
- Meatal stenosis
- Urinary retention
These conditions are relatively rare and may occur in the worst of cases. Overall, circumcision is relatively healthy and comes with several sexual and reproductive health benefits.
BJUI International: "Sexual satisfaction of women partners of circumcised men in a randomized trial of male circumcision in Rakai, Uganda."
Frontiers in Pediatrics: "Do the Benefits of Male Circumcision Outweigh the Risks? A Critique of the Proposed CDC Guidelines."
Global Health Science And Practise: "Sexual Satisfaction, Performance, and Partner Response Following Voluntary Medical Male Circumcision in Zambia: The Spear and Shield Project."
International AIDS Society: "Association between HIV and sexually transmitted infections and partner circumcision among women in uMgungundlovu District, South Africa: a cross-sectional analysis of HIPSS baseline data."
Johns Hopkins Medicine: "Greater Benefits of Infant Circumcision."
National Health Services: "Tight foreskin (phimosis and paraphimosis)."
The Scientific World Journal: "Complications of Circumcision."
Sexual Medicine: "Sex and Male Circumcision: Women's Preferences Across Different Cultures and Countries: A Systematic Review."
Stanford Medicine: "Complications of Circumcision."
Top What Are the Benefits and Risks of Circumcision Related Articles
Circumcision Pros and ConsThe list of medical pros and cons regarding circumcision is long. Though the American Academy of Pediatrics has repeatedly stated that "there is no absolute medical indication for routine circumcision of the newborn," it has been shown that uncircumcised men have a higher incidence of urinary tract infections, sexually transmitted diseases, and penile cancer than circumcised men.
CircumcisionCircumcision is a surgical procedure that removes the foreskin of the penis. Circumcision is generally a safe surgical procedure.
What Are the Do's and Don'ts For a Newborn Baby?First-time parents caring for a newborn baby? Learn what to do and what not to do for your brand new child.
How Is Circumcision Done?Circumcision, the surgical removal of the foreskin of the penis, is usually performed with local anesthesia in newborns, but older children, adolescents and adults may require sedation.
Is Circumcision Good or Bad?The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) states that there is insufficient scientific evidence to justify circumcision in young boys. Ultimately parents should make a decision on whether circumcision is in the best interest of their son. The decision should be totally personal and they should weigh medical information in the context of their religious, ethical and cultural beliefs.
Is It Better to Not Be Circumcised?Circumcision is the removal of the skin covering the tip of the penis. There is no clear answer as to whether it is better to not be circumcised as circumcision has medical, ethical, and cultural concerns.
New Parents MistakesParenting a child isn't easy. Explore the top 10 mistakes that new parents make. Discover newborn parenting tips for breastfeeding, learn to deal with crying babies, child's fevers, and more.
ParentingGood parenting helps foster empathy, honesty, self-reliance, self-control, kindness, cooperation, and cheerfulness, says Steinberg, a distinguished professor of psychology at Temple University in Philadelphia. It also promotes intellectual curiosity, motivation, and desire to achieve. It helps protect children from developing anxiety, depression, eating disorders, antisocial behavior, and alcohol and drug abuse.
Life After Baby ArrivesWhat are surprises new parents when they bring a baby home? Learn about infant sleep, getting help, adult relationships, and more, and discover how to make the most out of your experience with a newborn.
Parenting Guide: Healthy Principles That WorkGood parenthood isn't magical. It takes learning, dedication, and hard work. Learn how to set rules, offer love, and discipline children appropriately and set yourself on the track to becoming a better parent.
What Is the Foreskin Good For?The foreskin has several roles in penis health: protects the penis head, maintains sensation, reduces friction, and contributes to immune system function.
What Triggers Balanitis and How Long Does It Last?Balanitis is a condition where the glans penis, or head of the penis, becomes inflamed. Learn the signs of balanitis, its causes, how doctors diagnose it, and what you can do to treat it. Learn about balanitis and how circumcision can prevent it.