Test Your Supplements Savvy
How much do you know about your vitamin pill?
By Kathleen Zelman, MPH, RD, LD>
WebMD Weight Loss Clinic - Feature
Reviewed By Cynthia Haines, MD
Should you or shouldn't you pop one, two, or 10 pills full of vitamins, minerals, and/or other hard-to-pronounce dietary additives?
The decision about whether to take dietary supplements -- and, if so, which ones to choose -- gets harder all the time. It seems like nearly every day brings a new study that adds to the confusion about the role of supplements in our health.
Once a Day
Though people with certain illnesses or conditions may need extra supplements, experts agree that nearly everyone can benefit from a once-daily multivitamin that includes minerals. Even the best eating plans can fall short of meeting all of the 40-plus nutrients we need each day.
"Most Americans fall short of meeting nutrient needs," says vitamin researcher and Tufts University nutrition professor Jeffrey Blumberg, PhD. "It is estimated that only 3% meet the new dietary guidelines, and clearly we can improve the overall nutrient composition of most diets with a simple, once-daily multivitamin/multi-mineral pill."
There's no need to spring for an expensive brand, says Katherine Tallmadge, RD, author of Diet Simple.
"A generic brand is just as good as the best-selling brands," advises Tallmadge, also a spokeswoman for the American Dietetic Association. "Compare label ingredients and look for multis that include up to 100% [of the Recommended Dietary Allowances] of most vitamins and minerals."
Too Much of a Good Thing
When it comes to vitamins and minerals, there is such a thing as too much of a good thing. Dietitians have long warned of the dangers of excess vitamins and minerals, especially the fat-soluble types (vitamins A, D, E and K) ones that are not easily eliminated from the body.
"Individuals who start the day with a vitamin drink, eat energy bars throughout the day along with fortified foods, and [take] a cocktail of individual supplements risk developing serious vitamin or mineral toxicities," warns Tallmadge.
While illnesses resulting from mega-does of vitamins and minerals are rare, it's better to be safe than sorry, Tallmadge says. "The scientific research is lacking on the long-term safety of large doses of supplements," she warns.
Taking a daily multivitamin, on the other hand, won't put you at risk of overdoing it, says Blumberg. "The risk of dietary deficiencies is far greater than the risk of overdosing on vitamin and mineral supplements," he says.
Experts say it's important to keep in mind that supplements are intended to enhance, not take the place of, a healthy diet. That's because food offers so much more than vitamins and minerals.
"It is safer to get nutrients from foods than supplements because of the disease-fighting, interactive compounds; fiber; and phytochemicals that occur in food and do not exist in a pill," says Tallmadge.
New health benefits from various substances found in food are being discovered all the time. For example, in a just-published study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, researchers found that antioxidants found in certain brightly colored fruits and vegetables may offer protection against arthritis.
Test Your Supplement IQ
Take this quiz to test your supplement knowledge.
1. Which of the following conditions calls for taking a vitamin and/or mineral supplement?
e. Having a chronic disease
f. Eating a vegetarian diet
Answer: All of the conditions warrant taking a supplement.
For pregnant or nursing women, a prenatal vitamin ensures adequate nutrients for the developing fetus or nursing baby. Folic acid is very important, both before and during pregnancy, to prevent birth defects.
Smokers need extra vitamin C. This requirement can be satisfied by a supplement, or by eating more vitamin C-rich foods like citrus fruits, red peppers, strawberries, broccoli, and tomatoes.
Dieters can fall short of meeting their nutritional needs if they choose the wrong foods. The best strategy is to eat at least three meals a day and choose nutrient-rich foods like fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and low-fat dairy. To fill in the nutritional gaps, a daily multivitamin is the smartest approach.
If you have a chronic disease, a multivitamin is usually a safe bet. Check with your doctor to be sure that all your nutritional needs are being met.
If you're a vegetarian, your particular diet determines what supplements you may need. Vegans, who eat no animal products, should pay special attention to protein, iron, zinc, calcium, riboflavin, vitamins D, B-12, and A, and iodine. According to an American Dietetic Association position paper, a well-planned eating plan -- which may include supplements -- can meet your requirements for these nutrients. Seek the services of a registered dietitian to ensure your vegetarian diet is adequate.
2. True or false: Everyone can benefit from a once-daily multivitamin/multi-mineral supplement.
Answer: True. A basic multivitamin, selected for your age and sex, provides an array of vitamins and minerals to fill in any nutritional gaps in your diet. Most multivitamin pills provide up to 100% of the Daily Value for the nutrients they include. But there are exceptions: calcium and magnesium are too bulky to include 100% in a multivitamin.
If you don't eat three daily servings of dairy or use calcium-fortified foods, you probably need to take additional calcium. But most healthy diets that include spinach, legumes, fish, and nuts provide enough magnesium.
3. True or false: Supplementing your diet with a daily multivitamin and eating enriched or fortified foods is safe.
Answer: True. The choice is yours. Very few enriched or fortified foods on the market contain 100% of the Daily Value for nutrients. "There is a margin of safety built into vitamin and mineral requirements, and most safe upper limits allow for consumers to take a multi and enjoy fortified foods," says Blumberg.
Quick GuidePortion Control Tips: Lose Weight and Stick to Your Diet
4. True or false: Vitamins and minerals can expire.
True. All supplement bottles are required to carry an expiration date. Check the date and make sure you'll be able to finish the bottle before it expires. You may want to buy your multivitamins in smaller quantities.
5. True or false: Supplement marketers can make health claims without approval from the FDA.
Answer: True. Dietary supplements are regulated under a 1994 law exempting them from the same scrutiny applied to drugs. As a result, there are no guarantees about the safety, effectiveness, or validity of the claim.
6. True or false: Herbal remedies improve the quality of vitamin and mineral supplements.
Answer: False. Botanical ingredients aren't needed on a daily basis like vitamins and minerals are. Herbal remedies are condition-specific. If you want to take a botanical, use it in response to the particular condition, not like a daily multivitamin (and don't forget to check with your doctor first). Also be sure to check the label. Many supplements contain too small a dose of botanicals to offer any benefit, says Blumberg.
7. True or false: You can be healthy at any age without taking supplements.
Answer: True. There's no question about it: you can get all the nutrients you need from a healthy eating plan. The problem is that most of us don't, even with the best of intentions. For nutritional insurance, do your best to eat a healthful diet and make it a habit to take a daily multi.
8. What time of day should you take supplements?
a. Before breakfast
b. With meals
c. Before bed
Answer: b. Blumberg recommends taking supplements with meals -- ideally, with the largest meal of the day -- to maximize absorption and minimize stomach upset. But, he adds, whatever time of day you're most likely to remember to consistently take your supplement is the best time for you.
9. True or false: Supplements can boost your energy.
Answer: False. Despite some label claims, the only way to get energy is from carbohydrates, proteins, or fats (or even alcohol). Vitamins and minerals do not provide energy. Blumberg's advice is to stick to a basic multivitamin and avoid supplements with added botanicals or herbs that claim to boost energy.
10. True or false: Athletes need special supplements to enhance their performance.
Answer: False. Athletes who eat enough calories to cover their nutritional needs will get all the nutrients they need in their diets, Blumberg says. "There is relatively little evidence that athletic performance can be enhanced with additional vitamins or minerals," he says.
Published Aug. 25, 2005.
SOURCES: Journal of the American Dietetic Association, vol 103: pp 748-765. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, August 2005. Tallmadge, K. Diet Simple, 2004, LifeLine Press. Katherine Tallmadge, RD, spokeswoman, American Dietetic Association; author, Diet Simple. Jeffrey Blumberg, PhD, professor of nutrition, Tufts University.
©2005 WebMD Inc. All rights reserved.
Daily Health News
Nutrition and Healthy Eating Resources
Subscribe to MedicineNet's Weight Loss/Healthy Living Newsletter