What is electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)? What is the history of ECT? Why is electroconvulsive therapy controversial?
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is a non-medication medical treatment that addresses severe psychiatric symptoms, after trials of medications and psychotherapy have been unsuccessful or a mental health disorder is determined to be severe and acute enough to warrant this intervention. During this brain stimulation procedure, a health care professional passes an electric current through the patient's brain to produce controlled convulsions (seizures) while the person is sedated using general anesthesia. This device is often used in a hospital but can be done on an outpatient basis (the individual receiving the treatment does not stay overnight in a mental hospital or medical hospital).
Formerly called electroshock therapy or shock therapy, ECT is a form of mental health therapy that can be a life-saving treatment for people with some severe mental illnesses. It was based on a procedure in which seizures were chemically induced in patients using a heart medication (Metrazol). Health care professionals first performed the procedure in 1934 in Hungary to treat schizophrenia. In 1938, Italian psychiatrist Ugo Cerletti delivered electrical currents directly to a person's brain to induce seizures to treat schizophrenia for the first time. By 1940, psychiatrists were using ECT in the United States. The U.S. military often used ECT during World War II, after which it became widely used in American and European psychiatric hospitals. It was in the late 1940s that doctors started placing electrodes on one side of the brain (unilaterally) rather than both sides (bilaterally), which resulted in less side effects like memory loss or speech problems.
Despite those advances, ECT fell out of favor for at least a generation in psychiatry, starting in the 1960s. Rather than the popularity of psychoanalysis or the rise of medication treatments from pharmaceutical companies, it is thought that in addition to the significant adverse effects on memory and personality that bilateral ECT treatment caused, a cultural bias against psychiatry in general and against ECT specifically is the reason that this highly effective medical treatment became controversial. Novels like Asylum in 1961 and One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest in 1962, as well as the film based on the latter novel, released in 1975, are thought to have fueled some of that backlash by emphasizing the worst characterization of this treatment as shock therapy. The anti-psychiatry stance of groups like the Church of Scientology is also thought to have contributed to the stigma that mental health treatments, particularly ECT, incurred during that period.
Appreciation of the effectiveness of ECT started regaining ground in psychiatry during the mid-1980s with the publication of the National Institutes of Health (NIH) Consensus Conference on Electroconvulsive Therapy, published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), which documented how well this medical treatment improves symptoms of depression. By the mid-1990s, several guidelines for conducting ECT were published, providing predictability, standardizing, and thus credibility of this brain stimulation therapy in providing care for severe mental health disorders.
Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) Side Effects
Confusion is a change in mental status in which a person is not able to think with his or her usual level of clarity. Frequently, confusion leads to the loss of ability to recognize people and or places, or tell time and the date. Feelings of disorientation are common in confusion, and decision-making ability is impaired.
Confusion may arise suddenly or develop gradually over time.
Why do physicians perform electroconvulsive therapy? What types of
health care professionals administer electroconvulsive therapy?
ECT is quite useful in psychiatry for the care of certain patients with significant depression, particularly for those who cannot take or are not responding to antidepressants, suffer from severe depression, or are at a high risk for suicide. ECT often is effective in cases where antidepressant medications and psychotherapy do not provide sufficient relief of symptoms. Physicians often consider if a treatment known as magnetic stimulation therapy is ineffective. The effectiveness of this medical treatment has been shown for the depressive symptoms of both major depressive (unipolar) and manic-depressive (bipolar) disorders. Studies also show it to be a sound treatment in the care of people who suffer from mania, psychosis in the form of schizophrenia, schizoaffective disorder, schizophreniform disorder, and any severe decrease in movement and speech (catatonia). ECT is an effective treatment for people of a wide range of ages, from children and adolescents to elderly patients.
Availability of psychiatric hospitals that conduct this mental health treatment seems to be lower for ethnic minorities compared to Caucasians in the United States, and therefore minorities are less likely to receive this clinical intervention. Beyond what could be explained by age, socioeconomic status, insurance coverage, or by severity of the mental illness (severe major depression or bipolar disorder) of the patient, African Americans tend to receive this therapy less often than Caucasians in the United States. Worldwide, while older women with symptoms of depression tend to be the most frequent recipients of ECT in western countries, younger men with schizophrenia make up the group most often receiving this therapy in Asian countries.
Given the need for the ECT recipient to receive general anesthesia, medical professionals, usually psychiatrists, administer this medical therapy. Prior to starting a course of this medical intervention, the medical team will consult the patient's primary care doctor in order to determine that the person is physically able to receive the anesthetic and undergo ECT. Physicians, primarily psychiatrists, usually perform this therapy, assisted by an anesthesiologist and nurse, as well as a physician assistant and/or nurse practitioner to assure the safety and comfort of the patient by providing ongoing medical assessment and care.
Depression is a(n) __________ .
How does electroconvulsive therapy work? How does it treat depression and other illnesses?
This procedure works by triggering a massive neurochemical release in the patient's brain due to a controlled seizure. Research also raises the possibility that the seizures induced by ECT result in the generation of more neurons in the brain (neurogenesis). It is highly effective, in that the American Psychiatric Association describes it as being effective in about 80% of people with the potentially life-threatening mental illnesses previously described, often in people whose depression or other mental health symptoms have failed to respond to other treatments, like medicines and psychotherapy. ECT relieves symptoms of depression within one to two weeks after beginning treatments. After a course of ECT, some patients will continue to have maintenance ECT, while others will return to or continue antidepressant or other psychiatric medications to maintain their mental health on a long-term basis.
How do doctors perform electroconvulsive therapy today? What are the side effects of ECT? Why does ECT cause memory loss?
In recent years, the technique of ECT has improved. A psychiatrist usually performs this mental health treatment in a hospital, with muscle relaxant medicine and under anesthesia so that people receiving this procedure do not feel pain or discomfort. In addition to having the person's breathing, temperature, heart functioning, and blood pressure monitored during the procedure, the doctor will monitor for the desired presence of seizure activity in the brain using an electroencephalogram (EEG), since seizure activity is not always physically visible. Most patients undergo six to 10 treatments. A physician places electrodes on the scalp, usually on just one side of the brain (unilaterally). Then, the device passes an electrical current through the brain to cause a controlled seizure, which typically lasts for 20 to 90 seconds. A person usually needs six to 12 treatments for this medical therapy to be effective. The patient is awake in five to 10 minutes.
The most common side effects of ECT include brief confusion immediately after the procedure, as well as a temporary loss of short-term memory, which usually resolves within about six weeks. While placing electrodes on both sides of the brain (bilaterally) is thought to be more effective than unilateral placement, memory loss tends to worsen, even to the level of brain damage with bilateral treatment. Other side effects may include headache, high or low blood pressure, rapid heartbeat, nausea, and sore muscles, although the muscle relaxant given to the ECT recipient decreases the frequency and severity of muscle soreness. This mental health therapy usually can be done safely as an outpatient procedure as long as someone transports the recipient.
What does ECT cost?
The cost to the consumer for ECT varies depending on if the person has health insurance, if the insurance covers this procedure, and to what extent. The cost of each ECT session is about $2,500, for a total of $25,000 for the 10 sessions an average course of treatment entails. That does not include the cost of a hospital stay if necessary.
Where can people find more information on ECT?
American Psychiatric Association
American Psychological Association
ECT Resources Center
International Society for ECT and Neurostimulation
Mental Health America
National Alliance for the Mentally Ill (NAMI)
National Institutes of Health
Learn to Spot Depression: Symptoms, Warning Signs, Medication
Medically Reviewed on 10/8/2020
Ayoub, N.C. "Shock therapy: A history of electroconvulsive treatment in mental illness." The Chronicle of Higher Education. November 2007.
Breakey, W.R., and G.J. Dunn. "Racial disparity in the use of ECT for affective disorders." American Journal of Psychiatry 161.9 (2004): 1635-1641.
Ghaziuddin, N., and G. Walter. "Electroconvulsive therapy in children and adolescents." Journal of ECT 30.3 (2014): E37-E38.
Hauser, J. "An overview of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)." Psych Central 2016.
Hersh, J.K. "TMS or ECT? A mental health consumer weighs the options." Psychology Today 2013.
Kellner, C.H., M.M. Husain, R.G. Knapp, et al. "Right unilateral ultrabrief pulse ECT in geriatric depression: Phase 1 of the PRIDE study." American Journal of Psychiatry 173.11 (2016): 1101-1109.
Kellner, C.H., R.M. Greenberg, J.W. Murrough, et al. "ECT in treatment-resistant depression." American Journal of Psychiatry 169.12 (2012): 1238-1244.
Leiknes, K.A. "Contemporary use and practice of electroconvulsive therapy worldwide." Brain and Behavior 2.3 (2012): 283-344.
Levin, A. "Consent process said crucial at each ECT treatment step." Psychiatric News 2010.
Rudorfer, M.V., Henry, M.E., and H.A. Sackeim. "Electroconvulsive therapy." Eds.
A. Tasman, J. Kay, and J.A. Lieberman. Psychiatry, Second Edition. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 2003. 1865-1901.
Scarano, V.R., A.R. Felthous, and T.S. Early. "The state of electroconvulsive therapy in Texas. Part I: reported data on 41,660 ECT treatments in 5971 patients." Journal of Forensic Science 45.6 Nov. 2000: 1197-1202.
Scott, A.I.F. "Monitoring electroconvulsive therapy by electroencephalogram: an update for ECT practitioners." Advances in Psychiatric Treatment 13 (2007): 298-304.
Shorter, E. "The history of ECT: Unsolved mysteries." Psychiatric Times 2004.
Smith, G.E., K.G. Rasmussen, C.M. Cullum, et al. "A randomized controlled trial comparing the memory effects of continuation electroconvulsive therapy versus continuation pharmacotherapy: results from the Consortium for Research in ECT (CORE) study." Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 71 (2010): 185-193.
Suri, M.A.K., M. Suri, M.M. Adil, et al. "Indicators for electroconvulsive therapy among patients hospitalized for depression." Psychiatric Annals 45.3 (2015): 140-144.