Dandruff vs. Dry Scalp

The exact origin of the term is rather obscure. Dander consists of white to tan flakes found on fur or feathers. Ruff, the second syllable, probably originates from the word scurfy, which means scale arising from the most superficial layer of the skin. In any case, dandruff is the popular term for the small white flakes that conspicuously appear on the shoulders of your black sweater or blouse after your scratch your flaky scalp. This is distinctly different from the much larger white flakes and dead skin cells that can result from psoriasis, a skin disease that can respond to coal tar treatments.

Dandruff is not from a fungal infection that could respond to ketoconazole. Dandruff is also distinctly different from eczema (treated with cortisone creams) and contact dermatitis, which is an immune reaction to a chemical or metal.

A dry scalp is simply dry skin in the densely-haired area on the top of one's head. Dry scalp is not a medical term and really shouldn't be used to describe any disease involving excess scale noted in the hair.

Unlike other parts of the body, the scalp is naturally very oily and greasy. This is true for two reasons:

1. The skin in the scalp area produces more skin grease (sebum) that originates from hair follicles and the skin than any other anatomical region.
2. Realistically, the most anyone washes their hair is once a day, and frequently much less often than that. Shampooing with soap is responsible for removing moisturizing fats (lipids) that naturally accumulate on the scalp and hair to prevent dryness and flaking. It would require multiple washes per day of a hairless scalp to achieve significant drying (xerosis). Dry skin (xerodermatitis) does not just happen because of dry air, but it can occur because of hormones out of balance (such as hypothyroidism) and with increasing age.

A dry scalp is a common problem. The belief that excess scale in the scalp is ever due to dryness is almost always incorrect and can lead to mistreatment of the real cause. Therefore, the remainder of the article will refrain from using the term dry scalp.

The presence of dandruff in abundance is a clue to either the presence of an inflammatory skin disease affecting the scalp or a relative lack of shampooing. All skin constantly sheds dead skin cells, if one does not remove them, they will accumulate, appearing as white to yellow flakes on one's clothing.

Alternatively, an inflammatory skin disease affecting the scalp, such as seborrhea dermatitis (eczema), psoriasis, or fungal infection, can cause rapid growth of skin cells, producing excess scaling so abundant that it is often impossible to remove it even by shampooing frequently.

Dandruff is a sign of a potential scalp problem if it is present in excess. If one neglects washing one's hair, it is perfectly reasonable to expect to see dandruff. Simple regular shampooing will resolve the problem. On the other hand, if there is an inflammatory disease that is responsible for the production of excessive scaling, then treatment of this underlying problem can control the production of those unsightly flakes of skin.

If a disease is present, dandruff is frequently accompanied by itching.

A physical examination of the scalp skin is necessary to determine if a disease is present. Occasionally, a doctor may remove a portion of the scalp skin surgically so a pathologist can examine it to aid the physician in arriving at the correct diagnosis. Dermatologists have the most expertise in correctly diagnosing and treating scalp diseases.

The most common scalp disease producing excessive dandruff is seborrheic dermatitis. The cause is unclear (it is believed by some to be due to excess growth of the skin yeasts Pityrosporum or Malassezia), but a disturbance in the balance between normal scalp microbes has been postulated. It is easily controlled with safe, effective topical medications.

Seborrheic dermatitis is characterized by exacerbations and remissions and recurs if treatment is stopped. There is no known cure.

Medicated, anti-dandruff shampoos containing zinc pyrithione, coal tar, salicylic acid, selenium sulfide, or ketoconazole are effective at controlling seborrheic dermatitis. It is not unusual to supplement these shampoos with a medium-potency topical steroid lotion, solution, or foam applied to the scalp once or twice a day. There is little compelling evidence to suggest that either tea tree oil products (a single Australian study funded by the Tea Tree Oil Institute in 2002 using a 5% tea tree oil shampoo reduced dandruff in healthy individuals) or apple cider vinegar is of any benefit in controlling dandruff.

Since a variety of other skin diseases can affect the scalp, an examination by a physician with special expertise in treating and diagnosing skin diseases is recommended if nonprescription shampoos are ineffective.

If the dandruff is related to the infrequent use of shampoo, it often can be controlled entirely by more frequent washing. If it is due to seborrheic dermatitis, it is easily controlled with a variety of shampoos and the use of topical steroid products. These products do not cure the problem. If treatment is discontinued, the disease will eventually return. They should use effective treatment just frequently enough to control the problem. Excessive use is just a waste of money and will not improve the long-term outlook. Other scalp diseases causing dandruff require more specific treatments.

The best prevention is probably to use an anti-dandruff shampoo (medicated shampoo, such as selenium sulfide shampoo) as your regular shampoo frequently and regularly.