Vegetarian and Vegan Diet (cont.)
What are the potential health problems from consuming a vegetarian and vegan
diet?
Many people believe that it's not possible to consume all of your necessary
nutrients without meat in your diet. Vegetarian diets can be nutritionally
balanced, but it will take some planning to do this. Numerous studies have shown
that poor meal planning is the cause of nutritional deficiencies in vegetarian
diets, not the absence of animal foods. Well-balanced vegetarian diets have been
approved for all stages of life, including pregnant and lactating women,
children, adolescents, the elderly population, and competitive athletes.
The nutrients for which you are at risk of not getting enough will depend on
the foods that you have omitted from your diet. The following are the most common nutrients that
may be lacking in a vegetarian diet.
Omega-3 fatty acids
The American Heart Association recommends "consuming fish (particularly fatty
fish) at least two times a week." The fat in fish provides the essential omega-3
fatty acids, eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). The
omega-3 supplements and the foods fortified with it have varying amount of EPA
and/or DHA. Omega-3 fatty acids have been shown to slow the progression of
atherosclerosis, reduce triglyceride levels, act as an antiinflammatory agent,
possibly help with depression and other personality disorders, and possibly thin
the blood. There is ongoing research to determine if there are other health
benefits.
To a limited extent, your body can produce EPA from alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), another essential fatty acid. According to studies, ALA does not produce any
DHA, so it does not provide comparable health benefits to omega-3 fatty acids.
ALA can be found in non-meat sources such as flaxseed oil, flaxseeds, canola
oil, walnuts, and tofu. Research has shown that microalgae oil can serve as a
source of omega-3 fatty acids for vegans and vegetarians. Microalgae oil is rich
in DHA like fatty fish and provides an adequate amount of EPA.
One other thing to take into consideration when trying to obtain the health
benefits from omega-3 fatty acids is the amount of omega-6 fatty acids that you
are consuming. Omega-6 fatty acids are the other essential fat in our diet.
These fatty acids are found in abundance in our diets. So much so, that we
actually need to cut back on them. Omega-6 fatty acids are found in most
vegetable oils, soybean oil, corn oil, sunflower oil, and peanut oil. Some
experts state that we currently consume about 14 times more omega-6 than omega-3
fatty acids. The goal is to bring this consumption closer to an equal intake or,
at most, only 3 grams of omega-6 fatty acids for every 1 gram of omega-3 fatty
acids. Flaxseed oil and flaxseeds are the only source of ALA that does not also
provide omega-6 fatty acids.
While there are no official guidelines for how to get an adequate amount of
omega-3 fatty acids in a vegetarian diet, there are some recommendations that
you can follow:
- Use microalgae oil as a replacement for fatty fish consumption
- Use flaxseed oil or flaxseeds (ground or crushed) as your source of ALA. Do
not heat the oil when you use it.
- Cut back on your intake of omega-6 fatty
acids by replacing plant oils with olive oil or rapeseed oil.
Vitamin B12
Vitamin B12 is attached to the protein in animal foods. There has been
considerable research to determine if it is also found in some plant foods.
Unfortunately, the B12 that has been found in plant foods can't be used by
humans. Supplements that have been made with the plant sources have been shown
to contain B12 analogues, compounds that are structurally similar to B12 but do
not serve the same function. Research has shown that using supplements with
these analogues can actually compete with vitamin B12, inhibit its metabolism,
and increase the risk of B12 deficiency, a very serious condition that can lead
to anemia and irreversible nerve damage.
Vitamin B12 is found in seafood, dairy, eggs, and meat. Vegan diets have the
highest risk of deficiency. There are many foods that are fortified with vitamin
B12, so it is possible for vegan diets to contain adequate amounts of this
nutrient with or without a supplement. The recommendations for reaching your
vitamin B12 needs are to
1. consume food fortified with vitamin B12 two to three times a day,
2. take a
B12 supplement if you are unable to consume an adequate amount in your diet or
if you have an increased need for it (elderly, pregnant, and lactating women),
3. do not take excessive amounts of folate supplements, as this can mask a B12
deficiency, and
4. have your B12 level checked by your physician.
Calcium
The most well-known source of calcium is dairy foods, which are often
omitted or greatly limited in vegetarian diets and are completely omitted in
vegan diets. Dairy products provide 70% of the dietary calcium of the U.S.
population. The nondairy foods that provide calcium are calcium-fortified tofu,
some roots and legumes, and fortified soy milk.
Certain factors will impact how
much calcium you actually absorb from the food, such as the amount of calcium
that is present and the presence of vitamin D. The presence of vitamin D will
enhance absorption, while the presence of oxalic acid and phytic acid will
interfere with the absorption. Foods rich in oxalic acid are spinach, rhubarb,
sweet potatoes, and beans. Foods rich in phytic acid are unleavened bread, nuts,
seeds, and raw beans. You will absorb some of the calcium in foods that you
consume when oxalic acid and phytic acids are present but not as much as you
would when they are not present. For example, calcium absorption from dried
beans is about half of that absorbed from milk, and calcium absorption from
spinach is about one-tenth of that from milk.
The following are recommendations for consuming an adequate amount of
calcium:
1. Consume two servings of dairy products per day, with 200 mg coming from other
food sources.
2. Vegans should consume calcium-fortified
juices or soy milk on a daily basis, calcium-rich foods throughout the day, and
consider taking a daily supplement.
3. Calcium intake needs to be spread
throughout the day for optimal absorption. We do not efficiently absorb more
than 500 mg at a time, so there is no need to try to consume high amounts all at
once.
Iron
Iron is essential for health and transporting oxygen. A deficiency in iron
causes fatigue and decreased immune function. There are two forms of dietary
iron: heme and nonheme. Heme iron is found in animal foods, while nonheme iron
is in plant foods.
The amount of iron that the body obtains and uses from the food is referred
to as iron absorption. The iron absorption from heme iron ranges from 15%-35%
while the absorption from nonheme iron is only 2%-20%. There are ways to
increase the absorption of nonheme iron and meet your recommendations:
- Consuming vitamin C (citrus fruits, juice, red peppers) at the same time
that you consume foods with nonheme iron will increase iron absorption.
- Consuming meat protein at the same time that you consume nonheme iron foods
increases iron absorption.
- Calcium, tannins, and phytates interfere with the
absorption of iron. Tannins are found in tea and coffee. Phytates are found in
whole grains and legumes. Take any supplements containing calcium and foods
containing calcium, tannins, or phytates separately from the time you consume
iron-rich foods or an iron supplement.
- When you need a supplement, you want one
with ferrous iron salts (ferrous fumarate, ferrous sulfate, and ferrous
gluconate). The amount of iron that you absorb decreases with increasing doses,
so it's best to spread your supplements out over the day. Iron can be toxic at
high levels, so do not supplement if you do not need to and consult with your
physician before taking a supplement.
- Have your iron levels checked by your
physician.
| Nutrient |
Function |
Non-Vegan Sources |
Vegan Sources |
| Vitamin B12 |
Producing and maintaining new cells; helps make DNA; helps maintain
the nervous system |
Mollusks, clams
Beef liver
Trout
Salmon
Beef
Yogurt
Haddock
Tuna
Milk
Eggs |
Fortified foods:
Breakfast cereals
Vegetable stock
Vegetable and sunflower
margarines
Veggie burgers
Textured vegetable protein
Yeast extracts
Soy milk |
| Calcium |
Strong bones; contract and expand blood vessels and muscles; send
message to nervous system; secrete hormones and enzyme |
Milk
Cheese
Cottage cheese
Salmon w/bones
Sardines w/bones
Yogurt |
Fortified soy milk
Fortified juice
Tofu-made w/calcium sulfate
Soybeans
Soy nuts
Bok choy
Kale
Mustard greens
Blackstrap molasses |
| Iron |
Transport oxygen; regulation of cell growth and
differentiation; integral part of many proteins and enzymes |
Heme iron:
Chicken liver
Oysters
Beef
Clams
Turkey
Chicken
Tuna |
Non-heme iron:
Chickpeas
Lentils
Beans
Fortified cereal
Fortified
oatmeal
Tofu
Wheat |
| Omega-3 Fatty Acids |
Protect against atherosclerosis; reduce triglyceride levels; act as
an antiinflammatory; possibly help with depression and other
personality disorders; and possibly thin the blood |
Fatty fish:
Anchovies
Bluefish
Carp
Catfish
Halibut
Herring
Lake
trout
Mackerel
Pompano
Salmon
Striped sea bass
Whitefish
White tuna (Albacore) |
Source EPA & DHA: Microalgae oil
Source EPA:
Flaxseed oil
Flaxseeds
Rapeseed
|
Next: What are the benefits of a vegetarian and vegan diet? »