Prostate Cancer Report Cards Released
Five States Fail, Connecticut Heads the Class
WASHINGTON, D.C.-Five states failed the first-ever prostate cancer
state-by-state report card issued by the National Prostate Cancer Coalition (NPCC)
in time for June (Do it for Dad!-Men's Health Awareness Month).
"Many states are not doing even the simplest things when it comes to
fighting prostate cancer," NPCC CEO Richard N. Atkins, M.D. said. "Early
detection saves lives and far too many states don't encourage men to know th
risks and to get tested."
The report cards are a result of a study by NPCC where each state is
graded based on current prostate cancer screening rates, mortality rates and if
each state currently has laws in place guaranteeing insurance coverage for
testing. Screening and mortality rates are calculated from raw data made
available by the Center for Disease Control and Prevention.
Alabama, Arkansas, Idaho, Mississippi and Wisconsin didn't make the grade
while California, Connecticut (earning a perfect score of 100), Kansas and New
York earned A's.
Each state that failed does not have laws in place forcing insurance
companies to cover prostate exams. Only 28 states have insurance mandates
compared to 49 states that require insurance agencies to cover breast cancer
screenings-a disease with a nearly identical caseload. Utah, which was given a
"D-", is the only state in the union not to offer insurance for both prostate
and breast cancer screenings.
Two of the failing states, Mississippi and Alabama rank second and fourth
respectively in having the highest prostate cancer death rates. Meanwhile, Idaho
and Wisconsin rank fifth and ninth respectively in the lowest screening
rates.
Connecticut in the only state to rank in the top 10 in highest screening
rates and lowest death rates while the other three states earned B's in other
categories. Three other states, Delaware, New Jersey and Rhode Island, received
grades of an "A-".
Florida would have received a perfect score if it weren't for the absence
of a screening mandate.
"There are several states that could've scored A's if only they had
screening mandates," said Atkins. "Screening rates are already starting to
improve among the states that have recently adopted screening mandates like
Oregon and Washington."
Atkins added that Michigan would have gotten an A while Iowa,
Massachusetts, Montana and Nebraska would have received B's.
COMPLETE LIST
|
Alabama |
F |
| Alaska |
C+ |
| Arizona |
C- |
| Arkansas |
F |
| California |
A |
| Colorado |
B |
| Connecticut |
A |
| Delaware |
A- |
| DC |
C |
| Florida |
B |
| Georgia |
B |
| Hawaii |
D |
| Idaho |
F |
| Illinois |
C |
| Indiana |
C |
| Iowa |
C- |
| Kansas |
A |
| Kentucky |
D |
| Louisiana |
C+ |
| Maine |
C+ |
| Maryland |
C+ |
| Massachusetts |
C- |
| Michigan |
C+ |
| Minnesota |
C- |
| Mississippi |
F |
| Missouri |
B |
| Montana |
C- |
| Nebraska |
C |
| Nevada |
D |
| New Hampshire |
C- |
| New Jersey |
A- |
| New Mexico |
D |
| New York |
A |
| North Carolina |
B |
| North Dakota |
C- |
| Ohio |
D |
| Oklahoma |
B+ |
| Oregon |
C |
| Pennsylvania |
D |
| Rhode Island |
A- |
| South Carolina |
C |
| South Dakota |
B |
| Tennessee |
C+ |
| Texas |
B |
| Utah |
D- |
| Vermont |
D |
| Virginia |
C+ |
| Washington |
C+ |
| West Virginia |
C |
| Wisconsin |
F |
| Wyoming |
C+ |
States in bold are ones without an insurance screening mandate.
For more information, please read the Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA)
Test and the Prostate
Cancer articles.
Source: National Prostate Cancer Coalition (http://www.pcacoalition.org)
Last Editorial Review: 6/15/2006