Antioxidants and Cancer Prevention (cont.)
Five large-scale clinical trials published in the 1990s reached differing
conclusions about the effect of antioxidants on cancer. The studies examined the
effect of beta-carotene and other antioxidants on cancer in different patient
groups. However, beta-carotene appeared to have different effects depending upon
the patient population. The conclusions of each study are summarized below.
- The first large randomized trial on antioxidants and
cancer risk was the Chinese Cancer Prevention Study, published in 1993. This
trial investigated the effect of a combination of beta-carotene, vitamin E,
and selenium on cancer in healthy Chinese men and women at high risk for
gastric cancer. The study showed a combination of beta-carotene, vitamin E,
and selenium significantly reduced incidence of both gastric cancer and cancer
- A 1994 cancer prevention study entitled the
Alpha-Tocopherol (vitmain E)/Beta-Carotene Cancer Prevention Study (ATBC)
demonstrated that lung cancer rates of Finnish male smokers increased
significantly with beta-carotene and were not affected by vitamin E. (2)
- Another 1994 study, the Beta-Carotene and Retinol (vitamin A) Efficacy
Trial (CARET), also demonstrated a possible increase in lung cancer associated
with antioxidants. (3)
- The 1996 Physicians' Health Study I (PHS) found no
change in cancer rates associated with beta-carotene and aspirin taken by U.S.
male physicians. (4)
- The 1999 Women's Health Study (WHS) tested effects of vitamin E and
beta-carotene in the prevention of cancer and cardiovascular disease among
women age 45 years or older. Among apparently healthy women, there was no
benefit or harm from beta-carotene supplementation. Investigation of the
effect of vitamin E is ongoing. (5)
Are antioxidants under investigation in current large-scale clinical
Three large-scale clinical trials continue to investigate the effect of
antioxidants on cancer. The objective of each of these studies is described
below. More information about clinical trails can be obtained using cancer.gov/clinicaltrials,
www.clinicaltrials.gov, or the CRISP database at www.nih.gov.
- The Women's Health Study (WHS) is currently evaluating the effect of vitamin E in the primary
prevention of cancer among U.S. female health professionals age 45 and older.
The WHS is expected to conclude in August 2004.
- The Selenium and Vitamin E Cancer Prevention Trial (SELECT) is taking place in the United States,
Puerto Rico, and Canada. SELECT is trying to find out if taking selenium
and/or vitamin E supplements can prevent prostate cancer in men age 50 or
older. The SELECT trial is expected to stop recruiting patients in May 2006.
- The Physicians' Health Study II (PHS II) is a follow up to the
earlier clinical trial by the same name. The study is investigating the
effects of vitamin E, C, and multivitamins on prostate cancer and total
cancer incidence. The PHS II is expected to conclude in August 2007.