From Our 2010 Archives
What City Tops the 'Sun Smart' List?
Latest Skin News
Survey Ranks Cities by Their Residents' Knowledge of Sun Cancer Protection
By Joanna Broder
Reviewed By Laura J. Martin, MD
May 3, 2010 -- Not every city is created equal, at least when it comes to the residents' awareness of skin cancer prevention.
That is according to the results of a new online poll, "Suntelligence: How Sun Smart is Your City", a survey commissioned by the American Academy of Dermatology.
The poll examined more than 7,000 adults in 26 cities questioning them about their knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors about skin cancer detection, sun protection, and tanning.
Findings showed that those living Hartford, Salt Lake City, and Denver are the most knowledgeable about sun protection while residents of Cleveland, Chicago, and Pittsburgh are the least knowledgeable.
"One common thread we found encouraging is the majority of people polled expressed concern about skin cancer and had awareness of the importance of proper sun protection," William James, MD, a professor of dermatology at the University of Pennsylvania and president of the Academy, says in a news release. "However, we found that people's behaviors don't always correlate with their concerns."
The survey was conducted between Jan. 12 and Jan. 31, 2010; 7,116 people completed it. More than 200 participants took surveys in each of the 26 cities. An additional 1,123 people completed surveys outside of the study cities, which were used for the national comparison.
Residents of the highest- and lowest-ranked cities showed significant differences in skin cancer knowledge and practices when compared to the average collective responses for all surveys.
For example, 59% of respondents nationally had never received screening for skin cancer from a health care provider. However, in the top-ranked city of Hartford, 48% of residents had never undergone skin cancer checks. The two lowest-ranked cities, Chicago (No. 25) and Pittsburgh (No. 26), fared worse. Sixty-seven percent from Chicago and 69% from Pittsburgh admitted to never having had such an examination.
In another finding, 85% of respondents from Salt Lake City, the second-highest ranked city, disagreed with the statement that they are not too concerned about skin cancer because it is easily detected and treated, while 76% of respondents nationwide rejected this statement.
Where the appeal of a tan was concerned, 72% of respondents nationally believed that tanned skin looks good. In Pittsburgh, the second-lowest ranked city, 81% of residents had that impression, while in the 3rd highest-ranked city of Denver 65% agreed that a tan improves a person's attractiveness.
"We're hoping the results of this survey will draw attention to the public's need to change its attitudes toward tanning, which is the first step in changing behavior," James says in a news release.
He notes that if detected early, skin cancers can be successfully treated. It is a different story, however, when detection is late. The five-year survival rates for individuals with regional and distant melanoma are 65% and 16% respectively, James says.
Melanomas generally grow sideways before they grow deep, he tells WebMD, and while they are growing laterally they are not generally invasive, have less tendency to spread, and are far more curable than when they are detected later.
When detected late, melanomas are much harder to treat successfully, he says. "That's why people must be vigilant about protecting their skin from sun exposure and aware of the early warning signs of skin cancer."
Tips to Prevent Skin Cancer
To reduce the risk of skin cancer, the American Academy of Dermatology recommends the following tips:
Curious about how the 26 cities stacked up in terms of sun smarts? Check out their rankings.
No. 1 - Hartford
No. 2 - Salt Lake City
No. 3 - Denver
No. 4 - Tampa, Fla.
No. 5 - Boston
No. 6 - Phoenix
No. 7 - Atlanta
No. 8 - Philadelphia
No. 9 - Portland
No. 10 - Baltimore
No. 11 - Dallas
No. 12 - Houston
No. 13 - Miami
No. 14 - San Francisco
No. 15 - Washington, D.C.
No. 16 - Detroit
No. 17 - San Diego
No. 18 - Cincinnati
No. 19 - New York
No. 20 - Minneapolis
No. 21 - St. Louis
No. 22 - Los Angeles
No. 23 - Seattle
No. 24 - Cleveland
No. 25 - Chicago
No. 26 - Pittsburgh
SOURCES: William James, MD, president, American Academy of Dermatology.